Monday, 16 March 2020

What is the Gothic Part 1: Vaulting into Architecture


It occurred to us that we've been throwing the term Gothic around in the last few posts on the roots of the arts of the West without really defining what it means.



Thomas de Canterbury, fan vaults in the cloister of Gloucester Cathedral, 1351-1377

Beautiful early example of the Perpendicular Style - the last of the three phases of English Gothic. The Gothic style began in France and spread all over Europe, taking on regional variations. Historians divide the English and French into three stages each, but the features are different.  














In the last post, we made the claim that the Gothic period is where we can really start to see a split between the logical concept of art based on our Greek terms and the venal interests of a self-deifying elite. We've considered a lot of artworks from the later Middle Ages and looked at the change from a relatively productive feudal concept of noble to a parasite class that lived off the labors of the masses without contributing anything beyond some patronage of culture. But before we move into the basket of nonsense generally called the Renaissance, it makes sense to explain what the Gothic is, how it relates to society, and the connection to what comes later.



Dominique de Florence, Flamboyant Gothic entrance to Albi Cathedral, added 1392

The Flamboyant Style was the final phase of the French Gothic - roughly equivalent to the Perpendicular Style in England. 

The point of this post isn't to analyze every permutation of the Gothic, but to lay out the basic principles, important developments, and historical significance. 















This is going to be more of an art-focused post, rather than history or philosophy, although you can't really separate them. The idea is to work out what the Gothic was artistically, how it connects to Logos, why it was corruptible, and what it has to do with the Renaissance. Nothing too overly long - there are lots of good books out there if you really want to go deep - but for two reasons:

1. A way to take the pulse of the art of the West as we move onto the runway that will eventually bring us to modern times...



... and that accursed Armory Show of 1913 which is hanging in the distance like a grail.












2. A way to think about the relationship between art and Logos that is completely missing from the inverted Art! discourse of globalist modernity.

This will set us up for the next roots of the West post and a look at the Renaissance. We're also due for a more speculative philosophical post which will springboard from the Heidegger one and consider the relationship between art and ontology. In addition to occult posts and something more positive.

The Gothic actually has a connection to the sort of things we look at in occult posts since it was the victim of a satanic inversion in the early stages of modernism. Gothic art was first developed to praise God with beauty and awe. Now think how the modern usage is associated with dark horror and the occult. Anyone think its a coincidence that the soaring vaults and pointed arched of medieval cathedrals became settings for perversion and evil?



Relatively tame example of "dark Gothic" "art" from an internet search.

Consider the extent of the inversion to make the purest example of the artistic expression of Christian devotion into a symbol of moral decadence and depravity. It's easily taken for granted, but breathtaking in its perversion when you really think about it.

















Didn't think so. If they can't destroy it completely, they'll try and cover it with filth so it's unrecognizable then twist it into its opposite. Consider us a pressure washer.

As mentioned in an earlier post, the Gothic style starts in architecture. We looked at Abbot Suger and the Royal Abbey of Saint-Denis near Paris as a place where the distinction between sacred and secular really collapses artistically. The good abbot was obsessed with gold and gems in decorating his abbey, and the church itself was intimately associated with the French kings by its sprawling necropolis. But there was another side to Suger's philosophy. Put aside his lust for lucre and quarrels with St. Bernard and the austere Cistercians for a moment, and consider his defense of splendid decoration.





















Stained glass light falling on the royal tombs in Saint-Denis.


Suger argued that the light through his stained glass windows that glittered of his precious ornaments was an earthly metaphor for the far more beautiful light of heaven. And in his renovated choir, one came as close to experiencing the divine as possible here on earth. One thing the Band is wary of is linear thinking - that there can be one path, one explanation for something. Reality and motivations are complex. Suger was BOTH a materialist tool of royal power AND a believer in the power of beauty to lift the mind towards God. That they are ultimately contradictory is not that important - humans hold contradictory positions all the time.



Stained glass windows in Suger's ambulatory of St. Denis, ambulatory 1140-1144, windows around 1145






























So we can see two separate impulses in the aesthetic of Gothic beauty - a reference to the beauty of holiness AND beauty in the service of more worldly things. Looking back, it isn't always possible to untangle them, because the sacred and secular were intertwined in the medieval mind in a way that they aren't in our modern materialist culture.



Religious procession at Saragossa, Chroniques de France ou de St Denis, Paris, between 1332 and 1350, British Library Royal 16 G VI, f. 32v, 

It is true that Jesus told us to separate God's from Caesar's, but the reality in the Middle Ages is that Christianity was much more a part of everyday life. Most people viewed themselves as whatever their national identity was AND Christians at the same time. 

Life was simultaneously Norman or Scottish or Venetian AND Christian - there were different hierarchies and authorities, but everyday life brought the two identities together. 










Not that everyone acted like a zealot, but there really weren't "non-Christian" options to consider. And clergy were classified as one of the main divisions of society. Funding religious foundations and artworks, endowing masses for the dead, and building churches and chapels reflected positively on the donors socially AND represented good works in the the theological sense. That is, charitable deeds that were believed to bring God's favor.



Bishop Edington's Chantry Chapel at Winchester Cathedral, around 1346-1366

The chantry was the English version of a privately funded burial chapel. These were endowed to pay for masses for the dead and were made attractive to draw the prayers of passers-by, both of which were considered helpful to a soul in Purgatory. Win-win, because the church got funds and beautiful decoration. The practice ended when the Reformation axed Purgatory as a concept. 





So when we look at the Gothic, we have to be sensitive that it isn't an all-or-nothing thing like the dyscivic trash promoted as modern art and used as a money laundering vector today. It's more subtle -  between beauty that serves truth AND allure that glorifies base materialism and stuff.

So what is the Gothic? 

As we saw in the Suger post, the choir at Saint-Denis is considered the first example of Gothic architecture, but it is limited in scale. Some of the main features are here, but in a limited way.













And the key to the whole thing was vaulting.

Vaulting just refers to roofing a space in masonry - stone or brick - without needing intermediate supports like columns or piers. The simplest form of vault is an arch.




Arch of Alexander Severus, 228 AD, Roman triumphal arch in Dougga, Tunisia dedicated to Roman Emperor Alexander Severus

This is a semicircular row of stones cut so they are all narrower on the inside than they are on the outside. Once they are all set, each is held by the ones on either side and none fall in. You can see them in this picture of an ancient Roman triumphal arch.








The basic structure of an arch and different configurations. They all work the same way.

To build an arch, a wooden centering was constructed to hold each stone in place until the central keystone could be set. At this point, the structure is self-supporting and the support can be removed. Lower left: centering for a stone arch; lower right: Giovanni Battista Piranesi, The original Blackfriars Bridge, London, under construction in 1764, 1764








You can see where the term "vaulting" comes from - the arch seems to vault over the space from one support to the other.

Arches are extremely strong because their load-bearing ability is based on the compressive strength of the stones rather than the tensile strength, which is way more brittle. The only weakness is at the base. The weight of the roof and wall above the arch is transferred onto the  supports, but this also creates comparable lateral force and if the base of the arch isn't held in place, it will push outward and the whole thing will collapse.



Supporting the base strongly enough to counter this lateral force is called buttressing. The heavier the load that the arch is supporting, the stronger the buttressing has to be.

The Arch of Alexander Severus above is buttressed by its thick sides.









Pont du Gard, mid-first century AD,  Roman aqueduct inVers-Pont-du-Gard, France

A series of arches like a Roman aqueduct buttress each other by each counteracting the outward pressure of the one beside it.











Basic vaulting is very old - going back to Bronze Age Mesopotamia - but it was the Romans who made it a central part of their building. They built with a form of concrete that was faster and more flexible than stone, but the same physics of vaulting applies. Roman vaulting was so common that the basic round arch is often called a "Roman arch". And if you extend an arch over a distance to make a roof you get a barrel vault - the simplest form of vaulted ceiling.



Barrel vaults in the Roman amphitheater at Arles of 90 AD in the south of France. You can see that they are arch-shaped tunnels.











And just like arches, they needed to be buttressed. Along the full length, since they exerted arch-like pressure all the way along. 

The vaults at the amphitheater buttress each other like the arches in the aqueduct. 













The problem with barrel vaults is that they couldn't be opened up on the sides without compromising their structural integrity.  As an extended arch, they needed to be buttressed all along the sides for stability. Only being open at the ends was a problem for builders because it made large windows and doors impossible elsewhere.



You can see this in the barrel vaulted nave of Lisbon Cathedral, built in the second half of the 12th century. It's Romanesque, not Roman, but the same principle applies. There is light coming in from the rose window at the end, but no windows along the side walls. Those have to buttress the vault.  

















The Roman solution was something called a groin vault - two barrel vaults meeting at right angles and essentially leaning against each other so that all the weight of the roof channeled onto the four corners.  This allowed for openings in all four sides like famously seen in the Colosseum.



The groin vault is two intersecting barrel vaults configured so they support each other.  All four sides are open.

This did put a lot of pressure on the supports - in this diagram, the massive piers are able to buttress the outward thrust of the vault. 














And real Roman groin vaults in the Colosseum built in concrete between 70 and 72 AD. Compare it to the Arles amphitheater up above - it is much bigger and much more open because of the groin rather than barrel vaults. 



















After the collapse of the Western Empire the secret of concrete was lost. Vaulting was done in stone, and early medieval churches tended to have flat wood beam roofs. It was in the Romanesque period that we saw a few posts ago that vaulted interiors came back - both for fire safety and aesthetic reasons. Barrel vaults came first, and brought the same problems they gave the Romans - stone or concrete, they are terrible for letting in light along the sides. Early Romanesque churches were much darker inside than the older wooden-roofed basilicas with their big windows.

Early medieval churches had aisles running up the sides that were much lower than the main nave, and a timber roof allowed for windows in the walls above the aisles called a clerestory.



Collegiate Church of Saint Gertrude, consecrated 1046, Nivelles, Belgium

The side aisles are groin vaulted, but the larger nave has a wood beam roof. The bright light coming in the clerestory windows can be seen.











The barrel vault and its need for continuous buttressing mostly eliminated the clerestory as a possibility.




Abbey Church of Saint-Savin sur Gartempe, 11th century

The dark barrel vault is clear in this example. Saint-Savin sur Gartempe is unusual for the survival of it's painted ceiling. Most Romanesque churches were colorfully painted, but very little of this remains. You can feel the weight of the massive vault in the picture.

The Lisbon Cathedral above is another good example, though it's unpainted.

















The later Romanesque reintroduced the groin vault, which could open on all four sides. This way it could vault the bays of the nave and be open for clerestory windows. But these were still limited in size by an intrinsic limitation in the groin vault as a type. Groin vaults are just intersecting barrel vaults, and as such are massive, heavy structures. The exert tremendous lateral pressure at their bases and require a lot of buttressing. Given the height of the big Romanesque churches, the only available buttress was the mass and thickness of the walls. So even with the groin vault structure, walls had to be heavy and thick to support them and windows kept fairly small for safety.



Abbey of St Mary Magdalene, consecrated 1104, Vézelay, France

Clustered shafts support transverse arches and a groin vaulted nave. You can see the difference in the lighting, with the return of the clerestory windows. The walls are massive and the size of the windows is limited. 














The next step in the evolution first appears in Normandy, in the Abbey Church of Saint-Étienne at Caen. This building is considered an important precursor to the Gothic for its use of ribbed vaults to span the nave. These are much lighter than groin vaults and made it possible to start lightening the walls and expanding the windows. It still took some time, but the ribbed vault was a critical part of Gothic architecture.



Saint-Étienne, began in 1066, ribbed vault around 1120, apse replaced by an early Gothic chevet, 1166, towers and spires were added 13th century, Caen, France

Saint-Étienne is still massed and decorated in the Romanesque style, but the six-part rib vaults can be seen criss-crossing the nave and transferring the weight of the roof onto the vertical supports. 











Ribbed vaulting technology was fairly old - it appears to have first appeared in the dome of the Hagia Sophia in Constantinople in the 6th century, but to our knowledge, no one had used it for a nave until Saint-Étienne. In the Gothic it would be adapted into a primary building system. The idea is simple enough - instead of a heavy vault, span the space with a cage of intersecting arches, then use those the support a much lighter and thinner roof.



Hagia Sophia, 532-537, Constantinople

Emperor Justinian's palace chapel was converted into a mosque in 1453 and into a museum in 1935. It carries signs of the city's tumultuous history. The dome is a miracle of engineering - a cage of arches or ribs that carry the weight and allow for an almost unbelievable ring of windows. 

The ribs aren't as strong as a full vault - a masonry dome is just an arch rotated 360, like a barrel vault is an arch extended - but it doesn't have to be because it's so much lighter.















And a view of the ribs and windows from underneath, 

The structure is clearer from this angle. The ribs support the roofing material, so it doesn't matter if there are openings at the base of the places in-between. Those sections don't bear any of the load. 














When adapted to a nave, the advantage is clear. The only thick parts of the rib vault are the ribs, unlike the uniform thickness of the massive groin vault. The rest of the rib vaulted roof is filled with much thinner and lighter masonry webbing that is entirely supported on the ribs. 





Which brings us to Suger.

It's fair to say that Gothic architecture was driven by the desire to let in more light. Before you can even consider Suger's argument that his colored stained glass light was a taste of heaven, you need windows big enough to let it in. And Saint-Denis featured two defining characteristics of the Gothic that allowed just that: the rib vault and the pointed arch.



Good look at the rib vaults in Suger's choir ambulatory at Saint-Denis, built between 1140 and 1144. You can see the difference in thickness between the load-bearing ribs and the thinner webbing in between. The pointed shape of the arches is also clear. 









The lighter rib vaulted roof exerts less pressure, meaning less lateral force, meaning less need for buttressing. Walls can be less massive.



Diagram from the internet clarifying the relationship between the weight of the vaults, the outward pressure, and the thickness of the walls. 














And shifting the load-bearing capacity onto arches instead of the entire vault means that the buttressing is localized rather than spread along the entire vault. Secure the base of the ribs and the space in-between becomes what's called curtain wall - non load-bearing filler walls. The Hagia Sophia could have windows around the base of the dome because the ribs are doing all the heavy lifting. Suger's applies rib vaults to spaces that would traditionally have been groin vaulted, channeling a much lighter weight onto relatively slender supports. This transformed the walls from load-bearing to a system of alternating supports and curtain walls, The areas between the corners of the bays don't have to hold anything up and could become windows.





























The structural innovation - ribbed vaulting - enabled the aesthetic innovation - big jewel-like windows letting colored light pour in.

The other Gothic feature appearing at Saint-Denis is the pointed arch. The pointed vault has a clear structural advantage because its shape channels a greater percentage of the load thrust downward, and less of it laterally. Less outward force further reduces the need for buttressing and allows for even lighter and thinner walls.



Diagram showing the difference.











It's the pointed ribbed vaults that let Suger continue to build in stone while reducing the structural supports to thin piers and opening the space in between for glass curtain walls.

As an added benefit, ribbed vaults are more flexible. While groin vaults need to meet at  90 degrees, ribs can be launched across any spatial configuration. This is what allowed him to vault the irregular shaped curving bays of the Saint-Denis choir. So long as each rib arch is stable, they don't have to conform to a specific angular arrangement.



Plan of the irregular-shaped bays in the choir












And the irregular-configured ribs used to vault them. 
















But Saint-Denis is an introduction. The final piece of the Gothic puzzle has to wait a few decades until the the new pointed rib vault stained glass system was used to build an entire church. This was the birth of the Gothic cathedral -  first seen at Notre-Dame in Paris. But scaling Suger's style up to this size required a new innovation.



Cathedral of Notre-Dame, 1163-1345, Paris.

Notre-Dame is relatively small compared to later cathedrals, but a marvel of proportion and symmetry. Because it took so long to build there are different phases of Gothic style present. The facade was mostly finished by 1208, but construction continued on it until 1240.

The pointed arches are visible, and the thick verticals dividing the facade buttress the vaults supporting the towers.













Suger's choir was small enough not to face the challenges of extending the ribbed vaults and narrow piers to the full height of a big building. Even with pointed arches and lighter vaulting materials the outward pressure on such high walls would preclude big windows. But thickening the supports into buttresses like the ones on the facade would create a tunnel-effect around the windows that would block the light.

The solution was the flying buttress.


Flying buttresses along the nave wall of Notre-Dame




























These were essentially solid towers that were moved away from the wall, with arched "bridges" that met the exterior at the points opposite the base of the interior ribs. They created localized counter-pressure at the points where the lateral force was greatest and prevented the walls from buckling outward. The whole structure was locked into stable static balance leaving thin walls to let in the maximum amount of light.



View of the buttresses "flying" over the roof of the lower side aisle to counter the outward thrust of the nave roof rib vaults. The big clerestory windows in-between are unobstructed by a thick wall. 











And a cut-away diagram showing the parts of a cathedral and the intersection of flying buttresses and rib vaults.
















Flying buttressing makes the exterior look more like an exo-skeleton because it moves the support to the outside of the building. It's easy to see in this aerial view of Notre-Dame, with the buttresses running all around. 














But it allowed the interior to look like a miracle - a smooth, rising, series of supports holding a canopy-like roof over big stained glass windows. Aesthetically, the flow from the supports into the ribbed vaults create a feeling of soaring unity that is accentuated by the pointed arches.



Notre-Dame is modest by later Gothic standards, but it established a template and proof of concept - Suger's choir could be scaled up into a full-sized cathedral. The result - perfect harmony of structure and aesthetic bathed in colored light - was a point of departure. 













And a good shot of the vaulting and sense of verticality from below. It's easiest to see how the rib vaults create curtain walls for windows from this angle.














These are the fundamentals of the Gothic - pointed arches, rib vaults, and flying buttresses working togeather to open space for huge stained glass windows. A perfect unity of structure and aesthetics that realized Suger's dream of turning the church into a nearly supernatural glimpse of divine glory. And once the basics were worked out, Gothic architecture is a the history of refinement and adaptation across Europe.

Builders become more skilled and ambitious - raising the roofs ever higher while opening space for larger and larger windows.









Relative sizes of four Gothic cathedrals in chronological order showing the move towards bigger and lighter. Beauvais was never finished because the vaults were unstable. 


Chartres Cathedral is a bit bigger than Notre-Dame and was built much more quickly, giving it a greater sense of unity. The North tower was rebuilt in the early 16th century in the late Flamboyant style of Gothic, so it doesn't match. Otherwise it is probably the most consistent in style. It also has the largest percentage of it's original stained glass surviving, making it a treasure. Chartres more than the more experimental Notre-Dame represents the beginning of what is known as the mature or High Gothic, and provided a template for the rest of the High Gothic trio in the 13th century: Reims and Amiens Cathedrals.


Chartres Cathedral, 1194-1220, Chartres, France with a good view of the flying buttresses. 

Looking up into the vaults of Chartres shows the bigger windows.



The six-part vaults of Notre-Dame have also been replaced with a four-part or quadrapartite version that is simpler and more harmonious.










Chartre's windows are famous for the quality of their colors. Blues in particular.


















But the real marvel of Gothic stained glass were the huge rose windows that could take up entire end walls. The most spectacular were found on transepts - the smaller spaces that intersected the nave to make a cross shape.



Plan of Chartres with the main parts of a cathedral marked out. The south transept is the projection off the bottom side.









South transept of Chartres from the exterior. You can see the big round south rose window spanning the entire space between the roof vaults. The ribs are marked on the plan showing that the space in-between is non-load bearing curtain wall and free to be used as a window. 









The view from the inside is spectacular.



South Rose Window, Chartres Cathedral from around 1224. It is roughly 35 feet across. 































A detail of the glass. The frame is made of cut stone.















Unfinished Beauvais has the highest vaults of any French cathedral, but collapses and overall instability ended construction with the transepts. The choir was built in the 13th century and the transepts in the 16th, but the collapse of a planned 502 foot tower ended construction for good.



Beauvais Cathedral, 1225-1232 and 1238-1284; 1500-1548, Beauvais, France.

The cathedral as it looks today, showing the 16th-century south transept and the choir and apse with towering flying buttresses. 

The plan shows the 13th- century construction in black, the 16th-century parts in heavy gray and the unbuilt plan in light gray.





















The view into the 13th-century choir at Beauvais.


















The view from below shows the incredible height and the limits of French Gothic vaulting to make stone float on glass.
















The problem with describing and classifying the Gothic is that is spread and changed in different times and places. The English Gothic is quite different from the French that inspired it.  Even some of the buildings seen here were built over long periods with additions at later dates. Saint-Denis and Notre-Dame both have major sections that belong to different stylistic phases in one place. Plus the different phases of Gothic aren't precisely definable chronologically - changes happen in some places while the older style is still being used in others. They're more tendencies than hard distinctions. But they are tendencies, and we can briefly identify a few broad characteristics before wrapping this up.



The next phase in France is known as the Rayonnant Gothic. It appears between roughly 1240 and 1350, overlapping with the earlier High Gothic of 1200-1280. It more or less corresponds with the English Decorated Style, though that looks different and comes later.



The term comes from the French word for radiating and was first used in the 19th century when historians were trying to build a taxonomy of Gothic architecture off the design of windows. The Rayonnant was named for shape of the spectacular new kind of rose windows that began appearing at this time. 

Like the north rose window of Notre Dame de Paris,  1250-60

Obviously there's more to it, but compare this to the Chartres rose above and the difference is visible. The "spokes" radiate out much more clearly - Rayonnant - and the glass takes up a greater percentage of the wall space. The stone dividers are smaller and the glass fills out the bottom corners too. 








The Rayonnant is marked by a move away from the emphasis on monumental and rationally-ordered masses that we see in the High Gothic for a focus on linear decoration - both on two-dimensional surfaces and in space. In both cases, the effect is to obscure the massing of the building itself.

This can be seen on the outside of the north transept at Notre-Dame, where the above window is. It was built in a later stage than the nave we looked at above and is a good example of early Rayonnant. Compare it to the older main facade and you can see how the clear sense ordered massing has been replaced by a planar flatness and linear decorative elements.
































Even the gable above the portal on the transept is like a flat plane suspended in front of the facade, and all available space is filled with either windows or linear elements that look like they came from the windows. The impressions is one of less depth, less obvious structural logic, and especially less mass or weight.

It's even more obvious it its mature form, like at Saint-Urbain de Troyes. Here structural elements are hidden beneath decorative stone strips, the porch extends like a screen, and the window structure repeats on the facade:


Basilique Saint-Urbain de Troyes, facade built 1262-86


The development of the Rayonnant was triggered by an evolution in window design - a reminder that the stained glass window was central to the Gothic structurally and aesthetically. The earlier Gothic windows were made with a technique called plate tracery. Tracery is the term for the stone strips that support and divide the windows into patterned sections and can also be applied to other surfaces on a Rayonnant facade.



Western rose window, 1215, Chartres Cathedral.

Plate tracery - the tracery surrounding the lights - the glass part of a window that lets the light in - is relatively thick and heavy. It gets its name because the window looks like it was cut out of a stone plate.














The Rayonnant saw the development of a lighter, more delicate, and more flexible bar tracery. Here, the lights are separated by individually cut stone bars. It's first used in a significant way at the Reims and Amiens Cathedrals.



Max Švabinský, Last Judgment window, 1937, St. Vitus Cathedral, Prague

Bar tracery - the tracery is a web of bars that can be organized into more complex patterns while leaving more of the window opening free for glass.

This is a modern window, but an excellent illustration of the flexibility and openness of bar tracery.
















The switch to bar tracery allowed the huge walls of glass that defined the Rayonnant and seemed to dissolve the masses of the Gothic building. And the tracery strips could be applied beyond the windows - to make patterns on the facades like on the the north transept of Notre-Dame and to create screens above the entries like at Saint-Urbain de Troyes.

When the tracery is applied to a wall it's called blind tracery because the spaces can't be seen through - they're just surface patterns. When it's like a web or screen it's called open tracery for obvious reasons.



Blind tracery in the 13th-century tympanum of the western portal of Saint-Urban, Troyes, France











13th-century open tracery at Rouen Cathedral





















The technology of the Gothic didn't change with the switch from High to Rayonnant other than the new bar tracery windows - the buildings were still built with rib vaults, pointed arches, and flying buttresses as needed. It's an aesthetic shift. The builders grew more confident opening larger spaces with the same techniques and bar tracery turned these into radiant glass walls. Carrying the tracery beyond the windows onto facades and into open space lightened the appearance of the buildings into linear ornamental displays.

On the interiors, the Rayonnant transformation is dramatic. Here again Saint-Denis is a pioneer. Although Suger was long dead, his renovation and rebuilding plan lived on, and in the 1230s, the nave, transepts, and upper choir were replaced in the radiant new style.





























The entire upper wall had been flattened out and replaced with stained glass. There's a spectacular rose like the one at Notre-Dame, and the bar tracery in the pointed windows continues down past them to divide the arches in the gallery below. This is that same Rayonnant emphasis on surface ornament over mass that we saw on the outside taken inside.



Looking into the new choir, the contrast with Suger's surviving ambulatory is clear.

Bar tracery and glazed triforium in nave of St Denis (19th-century replacements). His smaller windows and early rib vaults seem dark and heavy in comparison. But if you look closely. you'll see that the structural elements haven't changed. Just the application.











One of the Rayonnant innovations was figuring out how to glaze the walls of the triforium. That's that gallery between the clerestory and the lower arcade that corresponded to the pitched roof over the aisles. Because it was the back of a right-angled triangle with the pitched rood as the hypotenuse, it was dark.



Here it is on a diagram.

The triforium was usually used as a secondary passageway and gallery since it wasn't practical for much else.



And as it appears in Chartres. 

Aesthetically it created a dark band between the lights of the clerestory and the side aisles in the High Gothic.

Saint-Denis used a new roofing method that moved water away in concealed channels and allowed for windows to be opened along the triforium wall. The relatively small openings and heavy supports were replaced with slender bar tracery. The dark band became another row of light, further lightening the interior. 

This also a good view to show how much the Rayonnant flattened out the interior as well. The effect is 2d decoration on an thin wall. When the Gothic is referred to a sort of skeletal building system, it's clear here.



Close-up of the clerestory and triforium windows with elaborate bar tracery frames and the thin verticals connecting the two levels.















So to generalize, the Rayonnant differs from the High Gothic for its appearance of relative weightlessness, flatness, and linear verticality. These are dramatic, but mainly aesthetic. The structural differences are comparatively minor. The basic building principles remain the same - pointed rib vaults and flying buttresses in suspension that open space for glassed curtain walls. The invention of bar tracery and refinements in roofing and water management allowed for bigger windows and more light within those basic parameters. The Rayonnant is distinguished from the High because it looks so different, but it's more accurate to call it an evolution in style rather than a transformation.

And no where do we see this immaterial appearence more clearly than at the Sainte Chapelle in Paris.



Thomas de Cormont, Jean de Chelles or Robert de Luzarches, Sainte-Chapelle, 1241-1248, Paris

This isn't a cathedral - it's much smaller, which is why you don't see flying buttresses. The roof was light enough that fixed buttresses would do. It was built as a reliquary - a place to house precious relics acquired by Saint King Louis IX, the only canonized king of France. 

The rose window on the end was added around 1490 and is in a different style than the Rayonnant. It's Flamboyant Gothic, the last stage that we'll look at in the next post. 











It's the interior of the Saint-Chapelle that makes it a true artistic wonder of the West. The upper nave is a single rib vaulted space with the walls looking like an unbroken ring of glass. There are 15 large windows not counting the later rose, each almost 50 feet high. Together, there are over 1100 panels telling the history of the world through the Old and New Testaments and the story of the relics up to the time they got to Paris.



The inside view. The pointed rib vaults are gilded, marking out the clear structural skeleton as they continue down onto the bundled columns. It really is a cage of glass - impossibly light and airy for a stone building. 

The contrast with the outside view is striking. 






























Looking up into the vaults reveals the Rayonnant at its most radiant. The flame-like appearance of the Flamboyant rose actually clashes with the harmonious linear immateriality of the rest of the structure. As we've seen, Gothic builders cared less about stylistic consistency than using the latest fashion. This is still a great picture of that perfect fusion of structure and aesthetics:





























The lighting adds to the supernatural effect:




The experience is a visual symphony of colored light that shifts and changes with the times of the day



The effect of the Sainte-Chapelle in twilight is more somber and mysterious than the jewel-like illumination of midday. 























And a final look up the windows, revealing that flat, linear, brilliant verticality that defined Rayonnant interiors. The walls just seem to disappear in a haze of light and color:





























The Rayonnant spread around Europe, like the Gothic in general. One of the most impressive examples of its mature form is in Germany. Cologne Cathedral was based on the design of Amiens and started in 1248, but work fizzled out in 1473 with only the choir and transepts finished. Construction didn't resume in a serious way until it was inspired by Romantic fascination with nationalism and the Middle Ages in 1842. The original plans for the facade had been rediscovered, adding further impetus. The cathedral was finally finished in 1880 and followed the medieval appearance, although modern building techniques were used. The decorative Rayonnant immateriality is clear it its towering form.



Cologne Cathedral, 1248-1880, Cologne, Germany

The huge Rayonnant facade is a 19th-century creation, but faithful to the 13th-century plan. All the features are present - the downplaying of structural clarity, emphasis on decoration, verticality, and liberal use of bar tracery in the windows and elsewhere. 
















On the interior, Cologne's medieval Rayonnant choir is a masterpiece of the style. The developments we say at Saint-Denis expanded to an even larger size.



The rib vaults open space for enormous clerestory windows, and the glazed triforium is striking. Cologne is very tall, but the verticality of the window shapes and the arrangement of the bar tracery accentuates that even further. 
























A closer look the clerestory and the triforium show that flat, immaterial feel that indicated the Rayonnant.























As the 14th century progressed, the Rayonnant gradually evolved into the final phase: the Flamboyant style. But this has been a long post - turns out that the pictures stretch it more than we thought. But this covers the essentials of the Gothic as a concept - where the vaulting came from, how it evolved into the Gothic rib vault and flying buttress system, and the two main stylistic forms - High and Rayonnant. We're going to stop here - if this post proves interesting to readers, we'll do a part two breaking down the Flanboyant Gothic and looking at the unique English versions. They come from the French, but quickly develop their own forms. We also need to look at Gothic art and how it leads into the Renaissance.

To relate this back to the roots of the West, we need to consider the relationship between art and Logos. We often say that Beauty is what the Good and the True look like, and the Good and the True are knowable to us through Logos. What makes the Gothic so special is the way that logic on different levels come together - all three levels of our ontological hierarchy to be exact. Click for the main post where we work this out.



The structural logic is material-level logos. Using the physics of vaulting with the material qualities of the stone and glass, Gothic builders created beautiful aesthetic forms that looked the way they did for practical reasons. Pointed arches are stronger. Ribbed vaults are lighter. Flying buttresses make walls thinner. Together they make the big windows possible. For all the mystical beauty of the Gothic, its parts wear their function openly. 




The aesthetic beauty of the structure is abstract level logos. Light and color to create an almost supernatural environment that is paradoxically based on structural logic, but pulls mind and soul away from the material. The Rayonnant in particular seems to realize Suger's dream of heaven on earth and bring you closest to immaterial things.



Together material and abstract point towards the logos of ultimate reality - capital L Logos. This is the true subject of all the structure and aesthetic and the inspiration for the sometimes centuries of effort that went into these. 










The skilled designers and craftsmen that built the cathedrals were highly sought-after and well compensated professionals. Yet they spent their lives on projects knowing that they would likely never see them finished. Generations could apply their talents to one site, accumulating efforts to the glory of God.

This is not to say that the Gothic is the "correct" form of art. Art is techne plus episteme, and techne takes different forms in different contexts.



But it is a correct form of art - the perfect synthesis of techne and episteme in the service of phronesis. Click for the application of our Greek terms to the arts of the West.




















The beauty of their truth blazes from their soaring windows. Logos drips from them in colored rivulets.
































There is much they can teach us.













Sunday, 8 March 2020

Prometheus and the Occult: Modernism, Postmodernism, Prometheanism


Constantin Popovici, Prometheus, 1965,  Vidraru Dam, Romania

If you are new to the Band, this post is an introduction and overview of the point of this blog that needs updating. Occult posts like this one - posts on the history and meaning of occult images - have their own menu page above. All  posts are in the archive on the right. 
Comments are welcome, but moderated for obvious reasons. If you don't see it right away, don't worry.



The last few occult posts have been looking at Prometheus. It's been a long historical journey because he's an old figure with a lot of associations.

Now it's time for modern Prometheus. Not just to recap the symbolism, but to consider a fundamental inversion at the base of modern thought.



No one really believes in Prometheus anymore, and the elites don't care about Classical culture and history. But Prometheus has become a modern symbol that ties into the de-moralized luciferian occult that plagues contemporary culture. We can even call it Prometheanism. Start with the lessons we have learned about the historical Prometheus and see what made him such a compelling symbol.

The myths have no fixed form - just general associations. From ancient times the Prometheus story had different parts that could imply different things. These include the creation of man, the education and enlightenment of man, rebellion against the gods' authority, and punishment for pride and hubris. When we take these together, we get more of a set of possibilities than a single character. So later people can use him for different purposes, even contradictory ones.



Alexander Kapralov, Monument to Prometheus, 1998, Orlinye Skaly (Eagle Rocks), Sochi

If the story focus on creation and education, he is a symbol of knowledge and progress. If it ends with his torture, he is a cautionary tale about overreaching. If it ends with his deliverance, it becomes the triumph of human initiative and will. And so on. 

Like this Russian version where the titanic figure breaks his chains with no eagle or Hercules in sight. Modern Prometheus often stands for the idea of human overreach as a good thing - that we can somehow overcome our physical and socio-psychological natures by tech and will. And if this sounds like luciferian magical thinking, well the good thing about art is that you can make it represent whatever you want. Reality doesn't matter.





Renaissance Prometheus ties into human vanity. Prometheus was transformed from a mythical character to an allegorical symbol to be applied to humanity in general. He was already just a set of associations - this just detaches these from any ancient context and makes him applicable to any time and place. This symbolically subverts the traditional Western Christian understanding that objective, transcendent truths are known by faith and pretends that they can be acquired by our own power.



Hendrik Goltzius (after), Prometheus Forms Man and Animates Him with Fire from Heaven, 1589, Metamorphoses by Ovid, plate 2, engraving, Los Angeles County Museum of Art

You can see the conflation with Prometheus starring in a creation scene where the arrangement is very close to Christian versions. The visual connects the two in ways that the stories do not. 






There were two parts to this Renaissance subversion. The first is seemingly innocent - that ancient culture was better, so it offered lessons that Renaissance Italians could use to improve their lives. But these lessons included a boatload of metaphysical nonsense that vain court sycophants humanists claimed on their own authority could modify and improve things that are by definition beyond our natural limits. And with this move, raw human desire starts to masquerade as objective truth - an intellectually monstrous inversion that will have terrible consequences. With Prometheus as a symbol.



Jacques Réattu, Prometheus Raised to Heaven by the Genius of Liberty and Protected by Minerva, 1792, oil on canvas, Musée Réattu, Arles

"Freedom" is an empty word that Enlightenment demagogues loved to throw around without ever really defining what it means in physical reality. Making Prometheus the centerpiece means that the "liberty" here is freedom from natural constraints through self-generated knowledge, or "wisdom", as represented by Minerva. As if things within the box can tell you what's outside the box.

Overreach - impossibly "escaping" an inescapable material existence inanely redefined as an "earthly prison" - becomes inverted. An impossibility - a lie - is transformed into not just a virtue, but a goal. The failure of the Enlightenment and the cultural wasteland that we inhabit in its wake was literally inevitable. You can't build on falsehoods and empty vanity.








In the modern era, soundly reasoned faith gets pushed aside and infantile magical thinking based on desire and vanity takes over. The Band has addressed this de-moralization in other contexts - click for the post where we explain the concept, and, if interested, for the post where we introduce it [the early posts didn't use the hyphen. This was added to differentiate the removal of morality from the lowering of morale]. The basic pattern is that advances in technology and knowledge are fraudulently presented as "proof" that humans can overcome their subjective, finite natures and reach transcendent Truths. This is the myth of Progress! - that we can endlessly improve in wealth, knowledge and capability in an observably finite system. It's so retarded it's irritating. But people are so drunk on their own vanity that they will propose patent absurdities like terraforming Mars rather than confront our objective limitations. Like this garbage:



Artist's concept of a terraformed Mars (left) and an O'Neill Cylinder; Artist’s concept of a possible Mars terraforming plant, from the article linked below.

Like this absurdity entitled "The future of space colonization – terraforming or space habitats?" from something with a name that suggests empirical rationality: physics.org. A good rule of thumb when assessing nonsense claims is whether or not the Science! is dependent on fantasy art to make its case rhetorically. It's amazing how much jibber jabber goes poof! when this test is applied. 

And as for terraforming Mars, consider that we can't terraform Antarctica. And space habitats? Watching them explode on the launch pad may provide some dark humor. But the real benefit of imaginary science is that you can imagine as diverse a team of imaginary scientists as you want...




We can see how we've stalled out now - burgeoning third world population, skyrocketing housing costs, education, media, and government replaced by webs of lies, perversion as mainstream culture. The list goes on The falseness of Progress! in human nature as a promise is obvious now.



Looking at current trends, a self-selected elite living apart and off of teeming struggling masses looks more realistic. Though even this fails to account for the massive population reduction that would follow the collapse of widespread advanced infrastructure and logistics.


















But it wasn't obvious to the turds in the Enlightenment who thought that their little theories could usher in Utopia. And when it quickly became obvious that they couldn't, it wasn't obvious to the fresh turds who declared everything subjective and ushered in Romanticism. And now the collective delusional vanity is such that modern turds actually will argue that that the limits imposed by human subjectivity means reality is unreal rather than admit that there are things out there that are beyond us. At which point irritating becomes pathetic and then self-destructive.

And so we get to modern Prometheus.



Ossip Zadkine, Prometheus, 1956, bronze, Paris

Like this ugly, late Cubist mess. Modern art is an expression of the modern Promethean perspective on culture - rejection of wisdom or legacy from the past for the deranged fantasy that we simply make up our future whole cloth. 

Humans are shaped by environment and genetic limits, just as art is a product of skill and beauty. The Promethean fiction is that we are "liberated" from external constraints - and empowered to do what we wilt. The result isn't pretty. Turns out just making up whatever we want doesn't yield much of value. 



















We'll set the stage with Modernism's extension and antithesis, and a central theme in this blog. That is Postmodernism, and what it has to say about the nonsense claims that the Prometheans live on.
















In the perfect Postmodern irony, the all the links on the site where this bit of Postmodern graphic design came from are broken.


An occult post isn't the place to get into the philosophical underpinnings of Postmodernism - regular Band posts are where we deal with that web of gibberish. It's enough for this post to point out the familiar characteristics - that there's no objective truth or meaning, everything is subjective, etc. What's important for us here is to distinguish the basic Postmodern conclusion that nothing is objective from the vile ideologies that make objective claims while professing to be Postmodern. Or post-Postmodern, if anyone gives a toss. Retarded fake belief systems like "social justice" are second-order effects - authoritarian scum taking advantage of the voids created when Postmodern cleaned out the old fake rules to introduce new fake rules of their own. Even the names - Post-postmodernism, meta-modernism, pragmatic idealism - are mentally-stunted faux intellectualism.



Simon Martin, Carlton, 2006, video, projection, colour and sound (stereo), Tate London

In practical terms, this distinction is irrelevant. No one cares if a cultural termite is a "true" Postmodernist or a "post" Postmodernist any more than whether a murderous thief is a true communist or democratic socialist. Or whether of not "the materiality of the object is subjugated to its historical context and cultural resonances" in a if a film of a bookcase taking up space in an art museum. They have to be opposed regardless. 



But the distinction is important if we want to understand what is going on, because any substantive cure needs a diagonsis.

If there is a Postmodern "logic"  it is oppositional. It both extends from and refutes the inane lies of Modernism that have progressively undermined Western culture for over a century. It is true that Postmodernity is anti-nationalist, anti-Christian, anti-human, and anti-truth, but in terms already laid out by Modernist anti-nationalism, anti-faith, anti-humanism, and anti-truth.

As an oppositional position, Postmodernism can't offer anything positive to replace the web of lies that it eviscerated. The nihilism of Postmodernism is specifically the destruction of Modernist faith, Modernist truth, Modernist objectivity, Modernist meaning, etc. It was the logical endpoint of nonsense Modernist claims - the demonstration that these claims were inherently fake and meaningless. If we call it a system of thought - which it really isn't - its conclusions are only relevant if we accept its Modernist starting point as a frame of reference.



Modernism sets the terms and Postmodernism deconstructs them. But deconstructing them is still taking them up - is still accepting the frame of reference that Modernism created. The answer to the Modern artists' claims of genius was "no you aren't". 










But in practical historical terms, the problem is that this is what happened. Our cultural institutions all did accept Modernist idiocy on faith, so when Postmodernism took a weed-wacker to it, there was nothing left to stand on. But the institutions continued as physical entities - buildings, staffs, budgets, etc. - so something had to fill the void. Modernism had already made our institutions anti-Western culture first and foremost - consider modern art, literature, social sciences, etc. The acceptance of Modernist ideology already meant that truth had been actively rejected. And an anti-Western, anti-truth orientation is independent of any one specific ideology, so Modernism could be expunged without changing this overall perspective.



Institutional carcasses aren't animated by arguments against Modernist idiocy. It's incoherent screeds in place of the now-debunked Modernism that share the same opposition to truth and Western culture. 






But the underlying vanity of Modernism isn't gone. If anything, it dominates our false beliefs that techno-utopias and state power can transform human nature. Put generally, Modernism is the objectively retarded claim that technical advancement gave humans access to pure objective Truth. That a never clearly defined "Reason" could define absolute laws of morality, control human nature, and unlock the secrets of the universe. The argument seems to boil down to this - logic is objectively true within it's own domain, and humans can perform logical operations like math, so "reason" gives us universal objectivity. It's literally that stupid, but incredibly seductive because it appeals to our vanity. And it's nothing new - Modernity just used new technology to supercharge it.



Gustave-Claude-Etienne Courtois, Adam and Eve, 19th century, oil on canvas, Musée des Beaux-Arts de Besançon

That somehow knowledge can make us gods is a delusion as old as the human species.














Compare this to the traditional West, where there are no human generated absolute "Truths". We acquire circumstantial knowledge through experience and draw conclusions inductively. Objective, transcendent, big picture truth are known by faith and applied to our circumstances deductively. These are the only paths to the respective domains. Empirical observation can't tell us anything about objective, universal, capital T Truths, and faith doesn't navigate the physical world for us.



Jadwiga Hawrylak-Grabowska, housing complex, Wroclaw, Poland. Built 1968-1973

From this perspective, Modernism inverted on both ends - it elevated our material impressions to the level of faith, then insisted that that fake faith determined the nature of the physical world despite empirical evidence to the contrary. Like this being an ideal way to live. Or pretty much any conclusion of the "academic" social sciences in general.










Postmodernism annihilated Modernist claims to absolute Truth with the sort of ease you'd expect, and revealed the fundamental inversion at the heart of it. Our language, perspective, formation, and context are all flawed, finite, and subjective. Our perception is conditional and our collective memory Swiss cheese. Modernism was the inversion of subject-object relations - contingent humans professing transcendent mastery. And none of this should cause a sensible person to even bat an eye.














Of course there is no transcendent truth available to our reason. Only a mentally-crippled Modernist ever believed that.

But where Postmodernism did become toxic is with how it replaced the Modernist nonsense in our dying institutions. Rather than returning to sound Western principles of empiricism and faith, it kept the Modernist lie that we master our own natures, even after destroying the arguments that that lie was built on. This opened the way to a fragmented and chaotic do what thou wilt - one where you could make up anything you want, and if you had institutional status, it was accepted as true. This was how chimera like oppression, hate, and diversity were simply declared articles of faith and replaced empirical observation and logic in in decision making. But there was no cogent reasoning - only whims enforced by state power. And the notion that power can force acquiescence to whims is neither modern nor postmodern.



Triad of Ramses II with the gods Amon and Mut, around 1270 BC, granite, Egyptian Museum, Cairo

It's as old as the first emperor claiming to be a god. 


And a quick note on deconstruction. The Postmodern argument against texts and images having objective meaning is often misunderstood and deliberately exploited. Obviously language is a form of reliable information transfer. We see that every day. 

What deconstruction shows that this information transfer is limited by the subjectivities of the language system and the people using it. It's not that there isn't meaningful communication. It's that the communication can't achieve pure, objective, transcendent Truth. We can't, so how could our tools?







Prometheus is the poster boy for the Modernist lie.

He was and remains, the pure symbol of human transcendence, in both Modern and Postmodern contexts. To the Modernists - the notion that human knowledge can overthrow the gods and usher in a state of rational perfection. To the Postmodernists - the notion that human striving and ingeneuity can impose our wills on an otherwise meaningless cosmos. But the irony is that in both cases, he is shaped by a fundamentally Christian thought pattern - just inverted in the typical Satanic way. This is the idea that humanity can fall or be saved, only fall and salvation are brought about by ourselves and not something external. And if that sounds familiar, it's because we're back in be your own god country.

To the Romantics, he symbolized the dangers of the human knowledge that the Enlightenment pretended would usher in a Utopia of pure reason. Our ability to bring about our own Fall, you might say.



Sir Luke Fildes, Houseless and Hungry, wood engraving from The Graphic, 4 December 1869

For example, those aspects of the Insustrial Revolution and Enlightenment that introduced the sprawling slum with new diseases and choking air.








Consider Rousseau - a pioneer of Romantic "thought" and a hollow gasbag with a knack for making up absurdities and selling them to other poseurs. His Discourse on the Sciences and the Arts (1750) [click for a translation], put him on the French intellectual map - the most intellectually overrated map in human history - for the "insight" that the advancement of human knowledge comes with a downside. He was typical of uni-dimensional Enlightenment darlings - a one trick pony whose one trick was empirically wrong. In this case, the idea that man in a "natural" state - without any trappings of civilization or technical knowledge - lived in a state of benevolent bliss. This is so stupid, so historically ignorant, that it is difficult to take seriously.

It is as if he saw a mythological Golden Age painting and mistook it for a true history.
























Follower of Abraham Bloemaert, The Golden Age, early 17th century, oil on copper, private collection
The mythical "Golden Age" was a Greek fiction that was no more real than Avatar.


The inexplicable popularity of Rousseau has two factors: hollow nature of Enlightenment-era "intellectuals" and their place in the de-moralized naval-gazing academic world that followed. At a time when most people had to work hard just to make ends meet, this intellectual was were a small, incestuous group supported by parasitic aristocrats living off inherited wealth and others' production. Success had more to do with satisfying patrons and impressing gatekeepers than any real intelligence or meaningful contribution to human understanding. Which is why Rousseau's Discourse reads with such a blend of pomposity and banality - he was writing for a vain and vapid audience where pretense trumped insight.



Pierre Louis Dumesnil, La conversation de salon Couleur, 1739, oil in canvas.

It's hard to imagine a bigger crowd of self-promoters, poseurs, and gammas, than a French "salon". Modern academics love these collective ego rubs because they tended to be organized by rich, do-nothing women. Symbols of feminist enlightenment! All the sycophants like Rousseau would compete to be noticed by some self-proclaimed doyenne in a home she didn't buy. 




The level of thought that emerged from the salons is about what you'd expect, and intellectual minnows like Rousseau should have disappeared with the passing of time. But that's where Modernist institutional ideology comes in. Because the Enlightenment was declared fundamentally important to modern de-moralization, this self-appointed intelligensia became immortalized by later self-appointed intelligensia. It didn't matter if his idiocy was wrong, because it was held up as "important".

All you have to do is go to a search engine - Google Books, an academic database, a university library - and search for Rousseau. Here's Princeton's on-line catalog for example.


























Look at the numbers. Literally thousands of books and articles wasted of a self-promoting fool who, if he hadn't existed, would have made no difference to human knowledge whatsoever. Though there is an outside chance that things would have been marginally better without the influence of his moronic blather. And consider this - the authors of all these books and articles aren't all idiots. Most were bright, hard-working, successful types with an aptitude for academics - the sort of people who could be useful to a society if productively engaged. Think of the aggregate brain power wasted on the endless recycling of Rousseau's asinine scrawl. One of many reasons why the modern university is actually harmful to society and needs to be replaced rather than reformed.

Prometheus appears on the frontispiece to the Discourse - Rousseau's first major work.
































It's the fire bringer version of the character - he appears to be animating or enlightening a human figure - only there's a half-human satyr coming in from the right who isn't part of the story. And there is a caption underneath that says: "satyr, you don't know that". The text includes a description of the picture:
"It is easy to see the allegory in the fable of Prometheus: and it does not appear that the Greeks, who chained him to the Caucasus, had a better opinion of him than the Egyptians had of their god Theutus. The Satyr, says an ancient fable, the first time he saw a fire, was going to kiss and embrace it; but Prometheus cried out to him to forbear, or his beard would rue it. It burns, says he, everything that touches it."
First, he gets the legend wrong. It's true that the Prometheus story is has different forms, but in no version is it the Greeks who punish Prometheus for his gifts. It's humanity that benefits and the gods that punish. But Rousseau wants Prometheus to match his idea that the Egyptians disliked their god of knowledge Thoth, so he just makes something up. Same with the "ancient fable", which is neither. The message is pretty much his usual one - that Prometheus was the knowledge bringer, and knowledge takes us away from the blissful state of nature. He adds: "our minds have been corrupted in proportion as the arts and sciences have improved."

The first thing to note is the switch from the gods punishing Prometheus to the Greeks.



José Clemente Orozco, Prometheus, 1930, Fresco, 240 x 342 inches (610 x 869 cm), Pomona College, Claremont, CA

Mural that captures the idea of Prometheus, fire, and humanity as a closed circuit. No divinities required.








The whole inversion of modernism is based on pretending humanity makes its own fate, rather than existing in a reality that is outside and beyond our mastery. The luciferian inversion of what is rationally best described as "mortal" and "divine". That we can be our own gods.

Then there is the danger of knowledge idea. Apparently it isn't dangerous for everyone. Several years later, Rousseau explained the frontispiece in his “Lettre à Lecat” [taken from Thomas M. Kavanagh, Enlightened Pleasures: Eighteenth-Century France and the New Epicureanism (Yale University Press, 2010), page 120]:
“Prometheus's torch is that of the Sciences, created to inspire great geniuses; that the Satyr who, seeing fire for the first time, runs to it and wants to embrace it, represents common men seduced by the brilliance of letters, who surrender indiscreetly to study; that the Prometheus who cries out and warns them of the danger is the Citizen of Geneva.”
The "citizen of Geneva" is Rousseau himself - a "genius" who can see past the dangers of knowledge that seduces and burns the common man. He distinguishes between geniuses who are inspired by knowledge, likely to flatter his peers, while emphasizing the negative effects on humanity at large. Humanity makes its own Fall, but also possess the potential for it's own salvation. Just have to listen to genii like Rousseau.

It's the negative aspect of Promethean knowledge that will be the Romantic pattern. A modern mural visualizes this better than any Romantic era picture.



Harold Freedman (designer) and Tony Barese, Joe Attard and David Jack (mosaicists),  The Legend of Fire, 1980-1982, mosaic,  Eastern Hill Fire Station, Melbourne

The Melbourne Fire Brigade mosaic is an impressive bit of public art that includes the divine source of Prometheus' fire, but takes an otherwise pretty negative view of his gift










The lower panels tell the story - the left one shows both sides of the gift and the importance of firefighters in dealing with the negatives. What you'd expect from a firefighter mural.

But the right panel brings Pandora onto the scene and the fire is nothing but negativity and destruction.
















A more straightforward Romantic era warning than Rousseau comes from Mary Shelly's Frankenstein (1818). It was even subtitled The Modern Prometheus. This refers to the famous scientist's creation of an artificial life that turns against him, killing those he loves before driving him to his own death.



Title page to the first edition of 1818

Victor Frankenstein becoming disgusted at his creation, frontispiece of the 1831 edition, engraving,  Colburn and Bentley, London 1831











Here, Prometheus is a reference to creation, and to knowledge in the Rousseau sense - as something that leads to a bad outcome. The idea is that human science will reach a point where it can replace what had been seen as divine - the creation of life - but the consequences will be deadly. It's a warning about overreach, about pushing past our "natural" place, and the consequences that will follow.

There's an almost endless number of stories on similar themes since - everything from new lifeforms to AIs - and the theme is always the danger of "playing God". Kind of ironic, since these stories always tend to be atheistic. It's almost as if the impossibility of creation ex nihilo is something even the most devout fingers in their ears and shouting retards can't help but sense subconsciously. Then again, the Modernism we're looking at is the inversion of divine creation.


An insidious contemporary version would be Ridley Scott's Pedowood trash Prometheus.



Prometheus, 2012, directed by Ridley Scott

This is a chapter in his Alien slaughter porn franchise - a long-running litmus test for moral emptiness. Here, the name refers to a spaceship piloted by a group of explorers seeking the "origins of humanity" only to be graphically butchered to titillate emotionally depraved modern culture victims the audience. Presumably the message is akin to Shelley's - don't overreach beyond your place or you'll suffer horribly like Prometheus - although there's really nothing linking the stories. At least as far as we can tell from summaries. The Band doesn't watch Pedowood slaughter porn.

This is the sort of fiction that is contrived to undermine the central place of humanity in creation - as made in God's image, and morally responsible for our own fate. By pretending we're second-rate offshoots of some other random species, it simultaneously denies that we're anything special while also lifting any spiritual responsibility. Created beings are what create life and the means of our own Fall. 



This is the Postmodern version of Prometheus. There is no dominant narrative of Progress! - just a random universe, but one where random sentient humanoids create life and we bring about our own damnation. The only thing that makes the "creators" important is that they created us - a purely subjective meaning to reality. But what none of these nonsense-peddlers ever address is the real physics problems that they space stories would need. This sort of creation story is utterly impossible just by the standards of the physical universe as we understand it. Simply the size of the power plant and the durability of atomic structures are sufficient to relegate this drivel to fantasy. But in the de-moralized world of idiot materialists, the materially impossible is preferable to the spiritually real.


There are "aliens"...































Gustave Doré, Lucifer, King of Hell, 1861–1868, engraving from Canto XXXIV of Dante's Divine Comedy, Inferno, by Dante Alighieri


They just don't come from space.


The more common modern Prometheus is superficially positive, but logically retarded and, not coincidentally, another bit of inversion. This is the symbol of man's limitless potential to challenge the divine and overcome limits with by the power of our intellect. This is the luciferian Prometheus - the firebringer that elevates us above our finite natures. And the punishment doesn't really factor in with this one. It's more fundamentally wrong than the physical impossibility of pushing a material lattice across interstellar space - the logical impossibility of infinite progress in a finite environment.



Maxfield Parrish, Prometheus, 1919, oil on panel, private collection

Parrish is a good artist. Here he captures the gist of this version of the Modern Prometheus. There is no punishment, and the figure of Minerva/Athena that represents divine wisdom in the myth has been added to the firebringer in the form of the symbolic helmet. 

Note how the torch of "divine" wisdom Prometheus touches names associated with technical and scientific Progress! He couldn't make the inversion of our place in the universe clearer if he slapped you across the face with it. 

We replace the gods through our own mastery of Promethean knowledge.













But this is the key to the modern symbol of Prometheus and the Promethian perspective. It is a rejection and attack on the basic Western understanding of human nature and salvation. It inverts the empirical and Christian notion that we are inherently flawed and require an external divine power to redeem us with an empirically false claim that we manufacture our own nature and destiny. The cautionary tales are that we bring ruin onto ourselves. So the implication of the positive version is that we'd be fine were we don't overreaching and do it right...

Consider: Kant called Benjamin Franklin the ‘modern Prometheus’ for his experiments with electricity and the use of scientific reason to control nature in the 18th century. Percy Shelley's Prometheus Unbound is dismissive of divine power and its hero the ideal man that leads humanity to a better state in the 19th century. Prometheus Books was founded by the same self-deifying buffoon that gave us the "Council for Secular Humanism" to publish self-deifying buffoonery in the 20th. A successfully cloned horse was called Prometea in the 21st.



LO Wenckebach, Prometheus, 1953, outside the Chemical Engineering and Chemistry building, Delft Technical University, the Netherlands.

Shimmying nude fire dancer lights the torch of knowledge above the entrance to institutional bloat. 
















We will damn or save ourselves on our own power - not just in a technical way, but that our technological advancement will fundamentally change what we are. We are the gods that write our salvation or damnation. We hold the occult power over the universe. Or so the Prometheans tell us...



Prometheus relief on a house in Dresden-Neustadt, 1900

What was once a symbol of man's treatment by and rebellion against the divine has become man replacing the divine. 

Doesn't really answer how we got here though. But Promethean globalists pretend the past doesn't exist. Every day is day one, and every tomorrow is Progress! towards the the Utopia to come.















As if our technology isn't bringing us a surveillance state, cultural degredation, unhealthy diets, parasitic globalist grifters in government, lying media, social justice in education, and every other cancer that comes with centralization. We may eventually destroy ourselves, but you don't even have to look at the logic to see we're not saving ourselves. Just look at the pattern trajectory.

How's that IQ decline over time graph shaping up?



Design Toscano Prometheus lamp, replica of 1864 sculpture John Bell

Perhaps a Prometheus lamp could brighten up the objective degradation of the species.



















Alternatively, ignore the logical and the empirical and just read Prometheus Rising (1983) by epic charlatan Robert Anton Wilson. Or don't. Infogalactic describes it as "an amalgam of Timothy Leary's 8-circuit model of consciousness, Gurdjieff's self-observation exercises, Alfred Korzybski's general semantics, Aleister Crowley's magical theorems, Sociobiology, Yoga, relativity, and quantum mechanics". In other words, the same old occult spray of symbols that we've been dealing with in these occult posts all along.

This would be the Postmodern version - no particular line of truth, just you making up whatever pastiche suits you out of whatever nonsense appeals to you. Instead of "human divine" wisdom making up collective salvation, subjective whims make up your own. Be your own god in a fragmented individual rather than collective way. So maybe don't read it. There's no truth to be found there. But then again, there is no truth to be found in globalist Prometheanism either.


Coming back to the Rockefeller Center where we started this journey, we can see the message in the golden statue more clearly now.


Paul Manship, Prometheus, 1934 gilded, cast bronze, Rockefeller Center


This Prometheus flies through the heavens carrying the gift of fire - no symbol of divinity or hint of punishment included. Placed in a prominent area in a complex built by and named for one of the architects of the modern beast system, it is the Modern Progress! version of the figure. This is made more obvious when we consider the figure visible on the building behind it - Lee Lawrie's Wisdom above the entrance.



Lee Lawrie, Wisdom, 1933, Rockefeller Center

Clearly a take on God the Father in the heavens, right down to the compasses that were an old symbol of divine creation [click for a post]. Only the creation is an abstract mechanical mess - the world of technological Progress! rather than any organic human existence. 

So the divine wisdom that Prometheus brings is the wisdom of the machine. Of human creation and ingeneuity. The collective message is that we are the creators of reality. And the globalist elites call the shots. 













Who are the Prometheans? The would-be masters of the world who seek to remake it in their own materialist, de-moralized image. To damn and save by their own means. To appropriate that which is logically divine to their own venal and contingent desires. In other words, the scum on the top of the globalist turd milkshake.

Maybe the best depiction of this collection of empty myths can be found in the Ukraine of all places - a statue where Prometheus teams up with another empty symbol of man claiming complete control over his nature and reality.



Prometheus and Statue of Liberty, Dneprodzerzhinsk, Ukraine

We haven't been able to track down the artist or date, but the symbolism is too perfect to pass up. Promethean wisdom is the path to "freedom". But freedom from what? Not globalist control. Not anti-human one-world fictions. Not fake morality, fake science, and fake institutions. Not censorship in the name of a Promethean agenda for everyone.




That's a good place to wrap, though we are going to have to look more closely at the symbol of the torch at some point. It's also worth considering if there is something in the Prometheus story that can be flipped around and turned against the occult masters of the world. But for now it's enough to see what Prometheus has come to represent.

We are finite, subjective, material beings. We are physically situated in a world of time and space that vastly outstrips us. It isn't a question of whether we "accept" that or not - it simply is. But we can pretend that it isn't, and in doing so tell lies that our surroundings aren't known empirically and our higher Truths taken on faith. It's wrong, it's inverted, but with enough wealth and power it can be forced by the elites through media and direct coercion. The lie is obvious when you need idols to fake gods to pitch it.

















Most Popular Posts